Grilled Cheese Sandwich
The perfect grilled cheese — golden, shatteringly crispy bread encasing a molten blend of three cheeses. The trick is low heat, patience, and finishing with a knob of butter for an irresistible golden crust.
Ingredients
- 4 thick slices sourdough or pullman bread
- 80 gsharp cheddar cheese
- 80 gGruyère cheese
- 60 gAmerican cheese or fontina
- 60 gunsalted butter
- 1 tbspmayonnaise
- 1 tspDijon mustard
- 0.5 tspgarlic powder
Method
- Mix softened butter with mayonnaise and garlic powder. Spread this mixture generously on one side of each bread slice — the mayonnaise helps achieve an even, ultra-crispy golden crust.
- Spread Dijon mustard lightly on the unbuttered sides of the bread (this goes inside). Distribute the three cheeses evenly between two sandwiches on the mustard side. Press the sandwiches together, buttered sides facing out.
- Place sandwiches in a cold skillet. Turn heat to medium-low. This is the key — starting cold lets the cheese melt before the bread burns.
- Cook for 4–5 minutes until the bottom is deep golden brown. Press gently with a spatula occasionally. Flip carefully.
- Cook the second side for 3–4 minutes until equally golden. If the cheese isn't fully melted, tent the pan with a lid for 1 minute to trap steam.
- Remove from heat and let rest for 1 minute — the cheese will continue melting and the crust will crisp further. Cut diagonally and serve immediately with tomato soup.
FAQ
The most common cause is too high a heat. Use medium-low temperature (around 140–160 °C on the pan) and cover with a lid for the first 2 minutes — the steam helps melt the cheese from the inside. Spreading a mixture of softened butter and mayonnaise on the bread surface also helps achieve even golden browning without burning. Patience is key: a perfect grilled cheese takes 3–4 minutes per side on low heat.
The best melting cheeses are Gruyère (nutty flavor, stretches beautifully), Emmental, and young cheddar. American cheese or fontina give an especially smooth, uniform melt without separation. For maximum stretch, use a blend: 50 g cheddar + 50 g Gruyère + 30 g fontina. Aged hard cheeses like Parmesan or Pecorino don't melt well on their own and should not be used as the main cheese.
Yes. Replace butter with a thin layer of olive oil, or use a non-stick pan with no fat at all. The flavor will be less rich but the bread will still brown. Another option is to spread only mayonnaise — it contains oil and egg, creating a crispy crust with fewer calories. For a low-carb version, substitute the bread with sweet potato toast or flaxseed crackers.
A grilled cheese is best eaten immediately — after 20 minutes the bread softens from the cheese steam. If you need to store it, wrap in parchment paper (not plastic wrap) and refrigerate for up to 12 hours. Reheat in a dry skillet for 2–3 minutes per side with a lid, or in the oven at 180 °C for 8 minutes. A microwave will make the bread rubbery and the crust soggy.
Use gluten-free bread made from rice or buckwheat flour — it toasts well and holds its shape. All natural cheeses (cheddar, Gruyère, fontina) are naturally gluten-free; just check the label on processed sliced cheeses, which sometimes contain starch. Most mayonnaise and Dijon mustard are also gluten-free. Cook on a dedicated clean pan to avoid cross-contamination.
Rate this
Recipes by email
One letter a week: a recipe picked for your taste, plus whatever is new on the site. Unsubscribe in one click.
Welcome gift: Sergei's cookbook (e-book).
By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.
Tell us what you like to cook (30 seconds) →Keep browsing
More dishes from the American archive — picked by overlap with what you're cooking now.
Join the conversation
Comments (1)
I cut everything for grilled cheese sandwich to bite size — nothing that requires a knife or causes an awkward moment. Appetizers should be effortless to eat so the conversation stays uninterrupted.