New York-Style Bagels
The New York bagel — the definitive version of this Ashkenazi Jewish bread — is one of the most technically precise breads in the home baker's repertoire. It is a lean dough (no fat, no eggs) made exclusively from bread flour, water, yeast, salt, and barley malt syrup. The low hydration (around 55 to 58%) produces an extremely stiff, tight dough that is kneaded until it is smooth and elastic. After an overnight cold fermentation that develops deep flavor, the shaped bagels are boiled briefly in water spiked with barley malt syrup — the boil gelatinises the surface starch, sets the outer crust, and produces the characteristic dense chew that distinguishes a real bagel from any other bread. They are then baked in a hot oven until the crust is a deep, crackled mahogany. Topped with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or 'everything' seasoning, they are served split with cream cheese and smoked salmon, or eaten warm from the oven with nothing at all.
Ingredients
- 500 gbread flour
- 7 ginstant yeast
- 10 gfine salt
- 1 tbspbarley malt syrup
- 290 mlwarm water
- 2 tbspbarley malt syrup
- 1 tbspbicarbonate of soda
- 1 egg
- 1 tbspwater
- 4 tbsptoppings: sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or everything bagel seasoning
Method
- Knead a stiff, strong dough. Combine flour, yeast, and salt in a stand mixer bowl. Add the barley malt syrup to the warm water and stir to dissolve. With the dough hook on low speed, gradually add the water to the flour. Increase to medium and knead for 10 to 12 minutes. Bagel dough is deliberately stiff and dry — it should not be sticky and should feel much tighter than bread dough. The finished dough must be completely smooth, elastic, and spring back immediately when poked. This protein development is what produces the characteristic chew. If kneading by hand, expect 15 to 20 minutes of firm effort.
- Bulk ferment then refrigerate overnight. Shape the kneaded dough into a ball, place in a lightly oiled bowl, and cover tightly. Leave at room temperature for 1 hour until slightly puffed. Then refrigerate for at least 8 hours and up to 24 hours. The cold overnight fermentation is the single most important step for flavor — it produces organic acids and complex aromatic compounds that cannot be developed in a short rise. The cold also makes the stiff dough easier to shape.
- Shape the bagels — rope method. Remove the dough from the refrigerator and divide into 8 equal portions (about 100 g each). For the traditional rope method: roll each piece on an unfloured surface into a rope about 25 cm (10 inches) long. Wrap the rope around your hand so the two ends overlap by about 4 cm in your palm. Roll the overlapping ends together firmly under your palm on the work surface to seal — this creates a perfectly even ring that holds its shape. The ring should be about 9 to 10 cm in diameter. Alternatively, poke a hole through the center of a ball with your thumb and stretch gently to a ring. Place shaped bagels on parchment-lined baking sheets. Cover and leave at room temperature for 30 to 45 minutes until slightly puffed.
- Boil. Bring a large, wide pot of water to a boil. Add the barley malt syrup and bicarbonate of soda and stir — the water will foam briefly. Reduce to a steady, vigorous simmer. Working in batches of 3 to 4 at a time, gently lower the bagels into the simmering water. Boil for 60 seconds, flip with a slotted spoon, and boil for another 60 seconds. The bagels will puff and float — this is correct. Remove with a slotted spoon, allow to drain briefly, and return to the parchment-lined baking sheets. Do not skip boiling: it is the defining step that separates a bagel from all other bread.
- Top and bake. Preheat the oven to 230°C (450°F) while the bagels boil. Immediately after removing from the water, brush the wet bagels with egg wash (egg beaten with 1 tbsp water) and sprinkle generously with your chosen toppings — the wet surface and the egg wash together ensure the seeds adhere firmly. Bake for 20 to 25 minutes until the crust is a deep, dark mahogany-gold and the bagels produce a hollow sound when tapped on the bottom. Cool on a wire rack for at least 15 minutes before slicing — the interior sets as it cools. Serve same-day for the best crust.
FAQ
The New York bagel is defined by three characteristics that commercial and non-specialist bagels typically lack. First, the dough is made with high-protein bread flour (13%+ protein) at low hydration (55 to 58%), producing an exceptionally stiff, tight dough that when baked gives a distinctly dense, resistant chew. Second, the bagels are boiled — not steamed — in water containing barley malt syrup before baking. Boiling gelatinises the surface starch, sets the outer crust to a specific thickness, and produces a characteristic shiny, crackled exterior. Mass-produced bagels are typically steamed rather than boiled because steaming is cheaper and faster — but the result is a thinner, softer crust with none of the chew. Third, barley malt syrup (in the dough and the boiling water) gives the specific malty, complex, slightly bitter sweetness that is the signature of a real bagel.
Rate this
Keep browsing
More dishes from the American archive — picked by overlap with what you're cooking now.
Join the conversation
Comments (1)
New York bagels are different because of the water. The mineral content of NYC tap water gives bagels their distinctive chew, and you cannot replicate it perfectly anywhere else. But you can get close. The two non-negotiable steps are the cold ferment overnight (24 to 48 hours in the fridge) and the boil in water with barley malt syrup before baking. The boil gelatinizes the surface starches and creates that shiny, chewy crust. Skip the boil and you have a bread roll with a hole in it, not a bagel.